How to read these numbers
It turns your contribution rate into cash, converts your match formula into the rate you need, and puts pre-tax and Roth on one table. The middle piece is the one people miss: a plan matching 50% of the first 6% needs a 12% rate, and every point below it is employer money you gave up.
Assumptions and limits
- Every rate, limit and match rule here is a reference figure. Check the IRS and your plan summary.
- The return is a constant assumption, not a forecast. Sequence-of-returns risk and fund fees are not modeled.
- Vesting is a straight-line approximation. HSA contributions, RSU valuation, required distributions and estate tax are not modeled. Not investment advice, and no plan or fund is recommended.
FAQ
Is the match on my contribution or my salary?
Both exist. Read the plan document: "50% of your contribution" or "100% up to 6% of salary".
Will my rate miss part of the match?
Check "rate needed for the full match". Below it you give up employer money every year.
Pre-tax or Roth — which wins?
Short horizons favor pre-tax: less tax now, and the deferral is an interest-free loan. Long horizons favor Roth.
What happens at the contribution limit?
Money above the limit leaves the 401(k): usually paid back in cash and taxed that year, or routed to a Roth 401(k).
Why isn't deferred tax money saved?
A deferral only postpones tax. A higher rate later, or a job change, can mean tax plus a 10% penalty.
If I leave the job?
Unvested match is usually forfeited. Vested amounts and your own contributions are generally yours to roll over.
Where does the 6% return come from?
An assumption, not a forecast. 6% is a typical long-run order of magnitude — try 4% and 8%.
I have no 401(k) — still useful?
Yes, as a target calculator: price a job with a match, then compare it.
Methodology
Year by year: contribution = min(salary × rate, annual limit); match = min(contribution × match rate, salary × match cap, annual cap); balance advances by balance × (1 + return) + contributions. Pre-tax net value is balance × (1 − tax rate). Arithmetic only.